Let's all revist history and go back to oct 1947

Rajesh Dhar First of all let me conceede, i am not a politician or student of history.These views are purely based on logical historical facts as per my comprehension...and i may be wrong as well. I am ready to stand corrected....

Let's all revist history and go back to oct1947.I am quoting here..if any one disagree's to my views please revert to that point only to avoid mix up.

Fact No 1 : It was left to Maharaja Hari Singh(No choice of subjects) to choose which way to go..either wth India, Pakistan or remain Independent.....He chose to remain independent.... See more

Fact No. 2 : Pakistani forces in disguise of Kabailees attacked Jammu and Kashmir to grab it by force.

Fact No. 3 :Foces of Maharaja were unable to check the invaders due to being small in number and logistics and lack of weapons.

Fact No. 4: Maharaja approached India for help. But Indian Govt put a condition that we will only help if you make J&K part of Indian Republic and sign the Instrument of Accession.

Fact No.5: Maharaja in consultation with Sheikh Abdullah flew to Delhi and signed as per the agreement/condition.

Fact No. 6 :After fulfillment of legalalities and making J&K part of the union.Indian Govt. rushed its forces to flush out the invaders who had come very close to city of Srinagar and were sucessful in capturing the major part back.

Fact No. 7: As India had legal position in its favour..Instrument of Accession, it approached UN for redressal.

Fact No. 8 : To maintain its policy of Peaceful resolution of the issue,India agreed to Ceasefire having faith in UN (Biggest Political and Diplomatic Blunder as per many political commentrators). Otherwise it was quite capable militarily to get all of J&K back.....This one mistake of india is the ROOT CAUSE of all the problems which is concerning all of us leading to Division of the state of J&K into virtually 4 parts.

Fact No. 9 : Now refer to various UN resolutions on this issue, which are self explanatory...for this you may have to go to UN's official website...as it will not be prudent to paste them here due to shortage of space. Read them and draw the conclusions. Especially de-militrisation of J&K and then holding the Plebescite/Refrundum.

Fact No: 10: But after SHIMLA AGREEMENT of 1972....the UN Resolutions became meaningless as it was decided that all differences will be sorted out by India and Pakistan BILATERALLY and no THIRD PARTY intervention is required or allowed.

Now the question remains..

1).who has to vacate the occupied parts of J&K first to bring back normalcy... obviously Pakistan as it has no Legal right..though it may claim moral/ethinic right.

2) Leagally speaking India is not the agressor, as it has Instrument of Accession on its side but it has no control over the will of the Majority of the people.

3) Till the time Pakistan will not vacate the occupied or so called AZAD and Northern region parts of J&K.....Plebescite can not be held.

4) India has already committed a blunder by referring the issue to UN in 1948..it can not afford to send a weak message on its stand once again.....ONCE BITTEN TWICE SHY.

5) First it has to be seen which country BENDS...FIRST.

6) After that only wishes of ORDINARY People like YOU & ME will be considered.......whatever happens/how many people get killed everyday/how many get displaced and separated...it doesn't and WILL NEVER MATTER AT ALL.

Keep praying that better senses prevail and we ALL WITNESS PEACEFUL SOLUTION TO THIS BLOODY PROBLEM.....in our LIFETIME.

Thanks for patient reading.....GOD BLESS US ALL.